During the pandemics, more and more people lost their job. At the beginning of the pandemic, states started to use a new federal benefit program created by the CARES to give out unemployment benefits. However, not every transaction was done correctly. Some people received more money than they should have. In an article from CNBC, Greg Iancurci writes how states can solve this problem.
According to Iancurci, the problem occurred because of the quick changes of the pandemic, the program being newly created, the high number of claims, and applicants making mistakes when they applied for the financial aid. The CARES, however, does not offer states a safety valve to forgive the overpayments. Some states tried for households to pay the "extra" money back to the state. However, there is a problem with this plan, because most households have already spent that money. In May 2021, Labor Department officials made rules so that states could ignore the overpayments in certain situations if they wanted to. The Labor Department also asked the states to pay back the "extra" money that they collected from the households. Michele Evermore, an advisor for the unemployment insurance at the Labor Department, explains why they do not want households to have to pay the "extra" money back. She says: "Otherwise, potentially millions of claimants have been or will be issued overpayment notices that will cause them to make drastic decisions with regard to how to reimburse states with money they do not necessarily have." This guidance from the Labor Department is optional, so states do not have to follow this guidance. However, Iancurci points out that the money used for aids is federal and not state money.
The certain situations where states can choose to waive the overpayments are when people did not respond correctly to application questions assessing the eligibility for the unemployment insurance, or when the state was at fault for the extra high payment. For example when the state miscalculated the amount of payment someone should receive.